East Los Angeles Renaissance Academy

Students should grade their teachers

Most teachers always think that they are right because of the fact that they have the title “teacher” when in reality they aren’t always right.

I personally believe that us as students should have the ability to grade our teachers and give them feedback about them and the way they do things. Based on my experience with a variety of teachers, I noticed that some teachers don’t care about what students tell them, which they should.

I hate the fact that teachers think that they have more power than we do just because we’re students. Teachers should allow students to grade them so that if they constantly see the same problem others claim they are doing wrong they can help us by making arrangements. Students shouldn’t have to wake up and not want to come to school because of the teachers they have. Teachers should have a good environment when it comes to their students coming to class.

Some teachers commit errors and make mistakes but don’t have the ability to own up to them. If a teacher is mad over something the class itself didn’t occur, they seem to always take it out on their students and don’t realize it. If we as students had the authority to grade our teachers, I strongly believe that it would make a huge impact on how us students are learning and getting our education. Not only would it help us, but it would benefit the teachers as well by becoming a better teacher. We have teachers to help us learn more about the subject we are taking. If the school and the district want us to succeed, grading our teachers would be beneficial.

My current literature teacher once told our classroom, “I am learning at the same time you guys are learning as well, we are here to make mistakes and learn from them.” We need more teachers like this because it helps us feel more comfortable learning and participating without having to think what the teacher or your classmates is going to say about your response. If a student is judged and graded by the teacher then the teacher should also be judged by the student.

Teachers are usually tested based on their knowledge they have based on the subject they are aiming to teach, but very rare on their teaching skills. Our opinions and the grade we would give them based on their teaching skills would not only help them but it could also help the school administrators to see how students feel about their teachers and their teaching skills.

I don’t see a problem with students being able to anonymously express themselves about their teachers. Who better than the people who are in the classroom every day with that teacher for an hour and a half be able to provide some insight as to how well that teacher is doing? The better they know how students of today learn the better they prepare them to educate the students of tomorrow. I am not here to judge a teacher’s attitude, if I want to become better in life, I believe teachers should show that as an example for us.

If you personally agree with me, let’s make this become a reality.

1 Comment

  • Reply Douglas Campbell November 9, 2017 at 1:27 am

    What you want already exists. It’s called ratemyprofessor.com, and is used to rate all manner of instructors, including high school teachers. But such sites, with individuals performing subjective rankings, is, in many ways, a popularity contest.

    Hence, the best method of rating your teacher is via standardized tests. You take one at the beginning of the year, the same test at the end of the year, and the difference is what you learned during the year. If you’ve taken these tests each year, your delta performance averaged over the years gives an idea of how good a student you are. But when your performance, and that of all (or most) of the other students drops below your average, that’s an indication of a bad teacher. When your performance, and that of all (or most) of the other students rises above the average, that’s a sign of a good teacher. Teachers do not exist for you to like them; they exist to teach, and this method provides an objective measure of the correctness of the teaching without personalities coming into play.

    The fact that a standardized test can be used to rate teachers rankles their union badly; a teachers union exists to provide secure employment for its members, not for any reason relating to student welfare. A badly ranked teacher may be fired, and that’s not a desirable outcome for the union. That’s a very big reason why you don’t see school boards militating for such a test; much of the money used to elect a school board member may come from the teachers union, and as a result, the board member may be beholden to the union, and the quid pro quo is votes for what the teachers want, even at the bargaining table where the board member really ought to be representing the voters who voted him or her into office. As a result, for such a test to be used as a method of rating teachers, much will have to change with how money is appropriated and used in education.

    Remember, when you hear “it’s for the children”, have a healthy amount of skepticism in this modern world.

    Like

  • Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s