Foothill Technology High School

Opinion: The education system is incentivizing mediocrity

The current system of grading, A through F, is a failing metric. This method measures a number of different things ranging from work ethic, dedication, willingness to make sacrifice and even tolerance for pain. Yet there is a key attribute missing from this list… aptitude. Wait!?! How can this be? The system of public education put in place to measure aptitude does nearly everything except measure aptitude?

The answer is yes, and the problem with this system is deep-rooted and long-standing.

Let’s take a look into the ordinary high school classroom. The majority of classes are subject to what is known as grade inflation. The curriculum is taught, homework is assigned and tests are taken. A seemingly normal situation. But, the problem occurs where the emphasis and weight among these categories is placed.

The problem begins when homework is given undue weight, within the overall grade, compared to tests. In many classes, it is possible to get a B or even an A when performing sub-standard on tests. The reason for this being grade inflation by homework. Conversely, it is possible to receive a C or even fail a class while performing proficient on test, or even excellent, yet choosing not to do the homework. You may be asking, well how do you know? I am unfortunately a student who has done both.

What could possibly be the reason for this? This is of course the next question in a logical train of thought. The answer is simple and unfortunate.

It doesn’t pay to have failing students, and it definitely doesn’t look good. Public schools, who rely overwhelmingly on the federal government for funding, are more likely to receive less money if test scores and pass rates are low. So the incentive is obvious.

Teachers, in turn, lower the standards of the classroom in order for students to “succeed.” And students do succeed by these standards. Yet proficiency is lost in the process. True success is lost in the process.

The problem also lies within a ridiculous mentality that I have often encountered. The mentality that putting in the requisite amount of work is equivalent to or of greater value than natural talent. The sometimes unhappy truth is that there will always be individuals who are better than you, and often times they put in significantly less effort to do so. People, understandably, do not like this; this mentality devalues success and excellence, and instead incentivizes mediocrity.

The solution to this problem would have to be on the national scale. Without even considering solutions regarding funding, the most logical solution would be to switch to a national proficiency based standard. Rather than basing education on subjective, moveable standards, they must be based on set and uniform benchmarks.

Education is one of the most important institutions in our country, yet it is not treated as such. Something must be done about the current state of education. Success must be prioritized over mediocrity.

–Christopher Haberbush

Featured Image Credit: Maya Avelar

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s