St. Lucy's Priory High School

Edward Snowden: The American Benedict Arnold

“Whistleblower” is too kind of a word to describe Edward Snowden. Traitor, Judas, and even Benedict Arnold are more befitting terms for a man who, three years ago, pilfered and leaked 15 million classified documents without the authorization to do so.

Knowing that he was breaking the law and would need to face the consequences of his actions, Snowden fled his residence in Hawaii to travel to Hong Kong.

While in China, Snowden leaked classified documents to the American public on the National Security Agency’s surveillance programs. Sometimes national security programs need secrecy to be effective. This is certainly true in the case of the National Security Agency (NSA), which has programs that depend on secrecy from targeted foreign terrorists.

In the case of these security programs, elected and judicial officials are charged with weighing the value of transparency against the national security benefits of secrecy. All three branches have approved the NSA’s programs.

Snowden has the right to disagree with the government’s decisions and actions. However, he does not have the right to usurp the democratic process by leaking classified national security information.

Snowden proceeded to release classified information about the U.S. military’s capabilities, operations, tactics, techniques and procedures. The leaking of this information only benefits those who wish to do our country harm.

Ed Morrisey, senior editor of HotAir.com, says “We should not confuse the necessity of the debate with the sanctity to the person who prompted it.”

Snowden is not a patriot, or an American hero. Snowden is a coward. He violated the Espionage of Act of 1917. He put our country at risk and fled to another country because he knew there would be consequences for his actions. This reeks of cowardice.

We cannot turn Snowden into a hero or patriot for opening a vital national debate on the balance between security and liberty, especially when he broke the trust of the United States government.

We cannot forget that Snowden traveled to Russia, with an unknown number of these documents in his possession, for asylum. Snowden lived in Moscow where he was given a one year asylum which has now been extended to three years. This says a lot about Snowden’s character.

A 30-year-old traitor flees to Russia, a country that the U.S. is not on good terms with. The frightening scenarios one can conjure up are endless. Who can blame us for being scared? Snowden could have put our country in greater danger by releasing the information he had with us to the Russian government.

Snowden is now asking President Obama for a pardon that he does not deserve. Snowden should return to the U.S., but only to be tried and punished for violating the law.

If Obama grants Snowden amnesty, others may take it as an okay to follow Snowden’s path and make the decision of what programs will have their information remain secret or not.

The choice before us is whether we want to celebrate a man who violates the law and if we would rather live with the government’s judgment or encourage unelected, unaccountable people to decide instead.

–Gabrielle Flores

3 Comments

  • Reply Sad parent October 22, 2016 at 1:00 am

    It’s a sad day when THIS is how misled and uninformed our youth are.
    The name calling is once again proven as an early warning system guaranteeing a regurgitation of the actual traitors’ (NSA) lies by a robot who can’t think for herself.
    Sickening! Snowden is a hero.

    Like

    • Reply An Informed Youth October 29, 2016 at 10:20 am

      It’s a sad day when THIS is a real reply .
      A man who steals American citizens’ information and takes it to Russia is no hero. I don’t know how much history you have under your belt (my guess is not much) but that’s actually called treason and it is punishable by death.
      It’s truly sad to see that the next generation will include people like your children brainwashed into thinking the government is out to get you.
      The only sickening thing here is the sad reality that there is people like you out there.

      Like

    • Reply Gabrielle Flores November 1, 2016 at 8:30 am

      Dear “Sad Parent”,
      I respect your opinion on Snowden and my editorial, please respect mine. I am a youth, but that does not mean in any way that I am misled or uninformed. I spent a great amount of time thoroughly researching this issue (both sides of it, actually) before I made the decision that I oppose Edward Snowden and believe his actions are sickening. I am not a “robot who cannot think for herself.” I am an intelligent, mature, powerful young woman who has been thinking for herself all her life. By the way, my parents are extremely happy and proud me. Thank you for your opinion, taking your time to read my story and comment on it as it has officially made me, in the words of my journalism teacher, “a true reporter.”
      Sincerely,
      Gabrielle Flores

      Like

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s